From the Field

Stories from teachers and students in our schools

Reviews

Reviews of software, websites, books, materials, conferences and events

Subject Areas

Languages, Social Science, Math, Science and Technology, Arts & Personal Development

Teaching and Learning

Learning theories in practice, educational approaches & structures for learning

Technologies for Learning

Technologies both good and bad - what to adopt, what to avoid

Parenting

The other educators in children's lives

Home » From the Field, Teaching and Learning

The Walk-through: Passing thoughts of a newbie one-year flash-in-the-pan principal

Submitted by on October 23, 2014 – 5:37 pm 6 Comments | 2,872 views
Image credit unknown

Image credit unknown

This post is the first of a series from new Principal Neil MacIntosh, as he reflects in real time on his first year on the job.

“The less you open your heart to others, the more your heart suffers” (NYT X-Word clue)

The answer was Chopra (as in Deepak).  I have found much of my inspiration and procrastination from crossword puzzles. I am not sure how far I can take this analogy, but humour me on this.    My DG and I had conversed about the qualities of being a principal – putting yourself 2nd, listening, listening, listening – and not with the intent of interrupting with your own pearls. In my quest to define what kind of principal I wanted to be, I eventually settled onto the idea of being what in Yiddish is referred to as a mensch – “The key to being ‘a real mensch’ is nothing less than character, rectitude, dignity, a sense of what is right, responsible, decorous” according to Leo Rosten. I interpret this as being in the moment and real with whomever you deal (with).  So perhaps your heart opens up, the more you listen to others. I find that by listening more and by reacting less (actions, words), that I put my foot in my mouth to a far lesser extent.  And then I’m better able to move to action to support the learner or teacher.

Recently, I read “A New View of Walk-Throughs” by Moss and Brookhart (Thanks to Julie Hobbs of ASSET).  First periods are free for me to greet and circulate through the different classrooms to be visible (as per Marzano’s School Leadership that Works).  The trick here is habit, so that the walk-throughs are not a rarity but become a regular occurrence – and damn the papers that pile up in my office.  This is not to see what the teacher is doing, but what the students are doing, what that they think they are doing, and seeing if they know why they are doing this.  It helps me also know what I did not know. In the first month here, I did not know what I did not know.  As Emperor Palpatine said “Young fool, only now, at the end, do you understand.”   Well, perhaps not that bad.   Now I see a bit more.  Having sweated myself as a teacher as principals over the past 26 years have wandered through my classes, I was relieved by the statements of Moss and Brookhart, who debunk these three myths of the walk through –

  1. Only the principal has the “deep understanding of teaching and learning.” Actually, walk throughs should actually be learning opportunities for principals.
  2. The use of a “one-size-fits-all criteria” to measure the ability of the teacher.  Time on task does not equal meaningful learning, and the primary goal of the walk-through is NOT to measure a teacher’s ability!
  3. “Top-down” decision making based on what the principal sees and filters down to the teacher, ignores the most important decision maker in the class – the student.

I use the walk-throughs as the beginning of discussions with teachers, supporting, asking for clarification.   I figure that I can improve the education of the students by supporting the teacher and having them know that I support them – the teacher being one major factor in the success of a student’s education.   My DG and I rhymed off the main (f)actors – teacher, student, parent – and my DG reminded me of the principal as a factor – hmm –had not thought of that.

Until next time!

Neil MacIntosh

Ed: Do you have any words of wisdom for Principal MacIntosh? I’m sure he would love to hear them!


References

Wikipedia entry for Mensch

A New View of Walk-throughs by Moss and Brookhart (you must be an ASCD member to read the full article)

School Leadership That Works by Robert J. Marzano, Timothy Waters and Brian A. McNulty

 

Tags: , ,

6 Comments »

  • Fascinating post, Neil. I think the walk through is a great idea, and I also think your DG is giving you a lot of valuable support and mentorship. I’m pretty sure you’re not a flash in the pan too! I look forward to reading more!

  • Dianne Conrod says:

    Neil, What a great idea to blog through your first year as a principal! Imagine being able to look back at all of your experiences/thoughts/developing ideas over the entire school year. Thanks for letting us peek at some of your reflections. You’re a mensch!

    Dianne

    • Neil MacIntosh says:

      Ahh, vibald du farshtaist dein narishkeit, bistu a kluger. If I know my foolishness, it’s not so bad, is it…

  • Jordan Kent says:

    I enjoyed reading your post. It’ll be interesting to hear how your thinking progresses throughout the year, so keep blogging.
    I really like the debunking of the third myth. I think the student, and their agency, often gets overlooked.

  • Ben Loomer says:

    Yiddish, Star Wars philosophy and views on leadership. If I had read this last week I would have sat beside you for longer at the Community Learning Centre conference.

    Funny and wise.